Aim to Be Gone

First published in Cook Partners, November/December 2008. By Kuruvilla Chandy.

Jawaharlal Nehru was India’s Prime Minister when I was in school. One day the newspaper carried a little item on Nehru’s response to the question of who would be his successor. The questioner no doubt wondered if Nehru was grooming his daughter Indira for the job. Nehru answered that he would be around for some time, so he wasn’t thinking about a successor.

When I read that, I thought to myself, “That is arrogance in the face of God.” Just that morning, I had read in my devotions, “Boast not thyself of tomorrow, for thou knowest not what a day may bring forth” (Prov. 27:1, KJV). About a week later, Nehru was dead.

For all his Western sophistication, Nehru did have a feudal attitude when it came to considering who would succeed him. He thought it had to be his own daughter—one from his own family, as though India were not a democracy but his private fiefdom. He was not ready to hand over leadership, because his daughter was young and not ready to rule over a bunch of old men. So he regarded himself as indispensable until his daughter could replace him.

Many people heading ministries and institutions cling to their jobs without developing a second line of leadership. Like Nehru, they assume that their own son or daughter will succeed them. When that does not happen, and time runs out, they select someone else for the job—often, someone who has been loyal to them personally, a proxy son or daughter.

Another scenario that happens far too often is that a leader does find a replacement but fails to let him or her know that that is the plan. If the person in charge gives no indication of a plan to quit, those who have an ambition for themselves will move on.

How do you see the future of the work you are doing? Does your vision for the work look forward to the time when you will not be there?

Vision

Who is responsible to make sure the vision for the work continues after the present leadership is gone?

Talwar was brought in to publish a magazine after a younger man was forced by circumstances to quit. A stopgap arrangement became a permanent one. Though Talwar is now really advanced in age and could die any time, he can’t be bothered about finding his replacement. The position gives him something to do, gets him recognition and opens doors. He hides behind the excuse that it is the board’s responsibility to find the next man.

The boards of Christian organizations consist of people who are busy in their own realms of life and work. Consequently, board members—while happy to sit in meetings—cannot necessarily be expected to take the initiative to actively search for the persons to take over from present incumbents.

Consider this alternative scenario. One year after a group of believers organized Shalom Church, Pastor Santosh said he needed to have an associate who in turn could take charge of the church. When he proposed that, the church had a total membership of about 80 people—including toddlers and schoolchildren, college students and retired folks with no great financial resources. The congregation met in rented premises. Most people felt that the priority was to get a church building. But for Pastor Santosh, the priority was not a brick structure, but a successor. He pointed out that he was young and strong and didn’t need an assistant. Moreover the church was small enough for one pastor to manage. This was not about him having an assistant, but about the church having a person in place for the future.

Pastor Santosh is immensely popular. The church would never ask him to quit. He could, in all probability, go on long after the date of retirement. Why should he bother with finding the next person, especially doing so might mean he would lose any chance of an extension of employment? For that matter, why should Talwar, the magazine publisher, search for a successor?

The New American Standard Bible (Updated) translates Proverbs 29:18 as “Where there is no vision, the people are unrestrained.” While the King James Version may not have translated that verse literally, it goes directly to the end result of running wild and stumbling: “Where there is no vision, the people perish.”

Most people have a vision for their own role at work. But unless they have a vision for the work after their own time, their vision is nothing more than an expression of their personal aims and ambitions. When you can see the work going on without you, then it is that you are a true visionary.

Making the Vision a Reality

Pastor Santosh insisted on the need for an associate for two years before the members got the point. It took another three years of searching before they were able to try out a person for the position of associate pastor.

Pastor Santosh guarded against taking advantage of the new man recruited to be his replacement. He insisted that Rohit was not an assistant, but his associate. (In India and other developing countries, assistants often lead a miserable life. Their bosses may be abusive, taking advantage of them and virtually turning them into their personal peons. Otherwise, they reason, what is the fun in having power?)

Initially Pastor Santosh shared the pulpit equally with his associate pastor. Later on he let Rohit fill the pulpit by himself for a full six months so that he could learn to be prepared to preach week after week without anyone else to relieve him.

Pastor Santosh loved to preach and had previously allowed others to fill the pulpit usually only when he himself was gone. It was unimaginable that he would sit without preaching for six months. But he did.

Pastor Santosh demonstrated an essential principle in dealing with those who are being prepared to replace one. It is not enough to insist on a person having all the paper qualifications for the job. Understudies must be given opportunities to try their hand at what you are doing.

I see this happening all the time at the barbershop. The newest chap is required to sweep up all the fallen hair from the floor. When he is finished with that task, he is allowed to watch the expert barbers until the next time he has to sweep the floor. After that he is allowed to give customers shaves. Later, he is allowed to take the scissors and try cutting hair—maybe a colleague’s, or of a customer who doesn’t care who does the cutting.

The same gradual upgrading of skills happens at the car mechanic’s shop. The apprentice starts with sweeping the floor and replacing the tools, moves up to removing or tightening bolts, and then to cleaning filters and checking spark plugs.

If you are a publisher, have you got a successor who is learning from you? Are you giving that staff member a chance to put your lessons into practice?

Who is indispensable?

When someone retires or otherwise moves on, it is the politically correct thing for those who bid the person farewell to say, “We don’t know how we will manage without you.” It is equally expected that the one moving on will respond, “Nonsense! No one is indispensable.” However, many live in ways that suggest otherwise.

A while back I read something written by an independent management consultant:

Big companies are announcing layoffs and closing divisions. Small companies are shutting down. Some people have been laid off multiple times in the last year as each new job ended in yet another layoff. Scary, isn’t it?

Given this environment, it seems that the best career advice I can give is on becoming indispensable … When I say ‘indispensable,’ I mean, ‘your manager will fight tooth and nail to keep you if at all possible,’ not, ‘your job is 100 percent secure.’

She then gave advice on what a person can do to make oneself indispensable in comparison to others, so that someone else is the one getting the boot. For example:

  • Do what you do better than anyone else does it.

  • Do it so well that no one can excel you, leave alone match you.

  • If you are the best, the company will be forced to depend on you.

Contrast that with the missionary Hudson Taylor’s attitude. In James Hudson Taylor: A Biography (Hodder Christian Paperbacks, 1965, p. 330), Taylor wrote in a letter home:

The Lord is prospering us and the work is steadily growing, especially in that most important department, native help. The helpers themselves need much help, much care and instruction; but they are becoming more efficient as well as more numerous, and the future hope for China lies, doubtless, in them. I look on foreign missionaries as the scaffolding round a rising building; the sooner it can be dispensed with the better—or rather, the sooner it can be transferred to other places, to serve the same temporary purpose.

Leaders who are centered only on themselves become indispensable. A servant, on the other hand, is vulnerable and dispensable, serving a higher purpose—nay, Someone Else.

Everyone in any Christian ministry ought to have one aim: to be replaced. We’re only the scaffolding that must eventually be dismantled.

Phase yourself out

John the Baptist got it right. He confessed he was not the main person in God’s plan. He said, “He must increase, but I must decrease” (Jn. 3:30). In Eugene Peterson’s wording, John says, “This is the assigned moment for Him to move into the center, while I slip off to the sidelines.”

Christian ministry is not about the Christian minister at all. It’s all about Christ and His people. “For we do not preach ourselves, but Jesus Christ as Lord, and ourselves as your servants for Jesus’ sake” (2 Cor. 4:5).

Paul was one who planned to phase himself out from the work he was doing, and he taught Timothy to follow suit: “Take the teachings that you heard me proclaim in the presence of many witnesses, and entrust them to reliable people, who will be able to teach others also” (2 Tim. 2:2, GNB).

You are here to promote someone else till you are effaced and replaced.

“Each one of us has received a special gift in proportion to what Christ has given … It was He who ‘gave gifts’; he appointed some to be apostles, others to be prophets, others to be evangelists, others to be pastors and teachers. He did this to prepare all God’s people for the work of Christian service, in order to build up the body of Christ. And so we shall all come together to that oneness in our faith and in our knowledge of the Son of God; we shall become mature people, reaching to the very height of Christ’s full stature” (Eph. 4:7, 10–13).

If you fail to advance and enable someone else in ministry, you have not yet served as a minister of God and have definitely not advanced the Kingdom of God.

Publishers and editors enable writers. But what about publishers enabling publishers-to-be and editors enabling editors-to-be? People are quite willing to help someone who is not doing the work they do. That’s easy—because they’re not going to replace them. But enabling the one who will replace you is hard. What if he or she proves to be better? What if their vision advances the work to such an extent that you are forgotten?

This is the truth that present day servants of Christ desperately need to learn: a Christian minister with vision has eyes only for Christ and His Kingdom. That is all he or she can see.

If you have a vision for Christ’s Kingdom you have to promote someone else till you are displaced. “Where do you see yourself years from now?”

The correct answer to that question is, “Gone!”


About the author

Rev. Kuruvilla Chandy is the pastor of Grace Bible Church in Lucknow, India. He is a well-known speaker and the author of several books. His articles on critical issues facing the church in India frequently appear in Light of Life and other magazines.


© 2008 Cook International. Presented courtesy of David C. Cook.

« Back to Publishing Resources